|Played By:||Anne Marie DeLuise|
A high school crush of Cameron Mitchell, whom he never had the courage to take the next step with. Whilst at school, Mitchell tried to talk to her many times but had always failed to do so.
Mitchell remininced about Amy Vanderberg a for a while with the Cameron Mitchell from an alternative reality, remembering how he could never ask her out.
Amy Vanderberg finally saw Mitchell during their high shool reunion, where she revealed that she was waiting for Mitchell to make the first move, whilst the latter was waiting for Amy to be the one who made the first move.